The story behind the #PIRANHACLAMP
- This topic has 54 replies, 12 voices, and was last updated 3 years ago by .
I (@carlf from the Kunststoffschmiede) will share with you the process of how we got to our final mould. It took us nearly 9 months and a team of mainly 4 people.
Don’t even think that we were full time on this clamp, but be sure: Product development takes some time…
So here it is:
The way from an idea to a functioning mould.
In summer of 2017 we finished building the injection machine, and made the first tests. One of these first test was the clothes peg.
We tried an old design from DDR. We replaced the metal spring with a plastic spring, but it didn’t worked out very well. The spring fractured quite often:( So sad…
Nevertheless it was a success, because we learned a lot about plastic, made an undercut injection mould and presented the first try with many other fancy community creations at the DDW’17.
So our main advise in product development: Failure is essential.
We made the spring thicker, thinner, shapeless and even, but it did not help. She was still breaking. So we came to the realization that we need a completely different design.
Anna made a research about clamps. There’re so many way’s of clamping your laundry. We never would have thought that:)
We wanted to have a clothes peg with just one part and Anna found a design on thingiverse:) https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:339768
As well as the first clothes peg, we made our first prototypes in plexiglas/acrylic glas (You want to know how it works? Watch the turorial on youtube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=24ECE3VL13k)
We tested it and it worked. Yes it worked:) Such a good feeling!
But we also had to notice that plexiglas isn’t the right material for the mould. Not in the long run. Because in the current design of the #piranhaclamp we have this tiny bridge from the inner circle to the outside. This bridge is too weak, so it easy breaks when you demould your clamp.
At first we had a working mould and a bad design. Now we had a bad mould and a good design. It did not feel like failure, but we still had not achieved our goal…
In the meantime, we have been able to establish contact with an injection molding company. The Schicktanz GmbH: 70km away from our workspace and very supportive.
They have their own workshop to build high-end moulds.
It ended up that they made the mould for the #piranhaclamp for free. Thank you!
Even if the mould was for free, it was a huge charge on our team to supply the right files. It is quite different if you make a testmould with plexiglas or give something in order, which is worth several thousand euros.
We made the last prototypes with the 3D printer.
And after a few hours of discussion we decided us for one design and made all files ready for Schicktanz GmbH.
Here some specs:
parting line: central
draft angle: 3%
engraving depth: about 0,5mm
curves: 0,5mm radius
First they milled a positiv of the clamp out of copper. This copper electrode was used to burn (EDM technique) the form of the clamp into the metal mould. Here are some pictures of the production.
The last steps we have to make is the engraving of the plastic type (we purposely left it out to test if PP is the right plastic) and to find the fastest way to open and close the mould
I hope I could explain it to you well! Feel free to write every question or remark in this topic;-)
Besides we are testing all use cases we can imagine;-)
What comes next?
Awesome, thanks for sharing!
Hey @kunststoffschmiede !
Thanks for the sharing of tall that work; very interesting to follow the “walls” you encountered in the whole process !
So if I am correct; you decided to use PP for your Piranhaclamp?
Is there any reason why the molding may not be able with other types ?
Also; i am curious how you operate the cooling on the molded product; do you let it cool naturally or do you force it with fresh water cooling?
Does your product warp much after cooling ?
Looking forward to read more about this project;
Hey @carlf this is a fantastic topic. Thanks for sharing. So much knowledge ❤️.
I think this topic needs the space it deserves. Would you like to write (copy and paste 😀) a guest post for our news section?
Also, this needs to be on our Bazar, yes or yes 😇
Keep up the great work.
Great news coming soon
well yes, we didn’t test other types:) but for all we know, pp is one of the most flexible types of plastic.
maybe we will use an external tool to brand. currently we are testing the dremel versa tip. in this case we would be free to try other types. but for every clamp it’s another step.
we don’t cool or preheat the mould. all natural:)
in the beginning the clamp shrinks a lot and it’s a little bit difficult to demould it. after some injections the mould is a little bit cozy, then it’s very easy to demould the clamp.
as a generel rule you can work with 2-3% of shrinking. it also depends on how much pressure you give.
inspiring topic! Going to use this one as an example for proper documentation 🙏well done
Awesome work, thanks for sharing
Or upload it somewhere else and post a link.
@kunststoffschmiede : same here, we’d like to have the CAD files, could you please put them in github repo, so everyone can find it ?
Are you actually happy to share the design for the clamp, or for people to copy your idea/produce it themselves? Precious Plastics is based on the open source model and most people here assume that other peoples designs are presented as free to use, even disagreeing with the idea of intellectual property and patents/copyright.
However you have obviously put a lot of time and money into designing and perfecting this and it’s understandable you might not want somebody else to take all the results of that and just use it for their own purposes, possibly making a profit from it or competing with you/ taking credit without acknowledging or even appreciating what’s gone into it.
So if you’d rather other people didn’t use your designs I think we ought to respect that, it doesn’t diminish in any what what you’ve achieved, and it’s still appropriate for you to post here to showcase what you’e created, I find the story behind the evolution of the design particularly interesting.
Hey, sorry to all of you! The past month I was travalling through Kenya without internet…
I have just arrived… for these two points i need some time 😉
1. I’ll have to check what I can share with you. I’m sure we will upload the files. But Kunststoffschmiede is a group of a few people and I have to check if the majority agrees with it.
2. Translate the technical drawings into english
@adyn, I have just contacted them yesterday on Facebook. I am sure they are happy to share as much they can. The problem is rather that the guy who made the mold (external) has all the rights first, and so they are trying to contacting him right now. But I fully agree with the general direction of your question. I asked myself recently too: so now we have the machines but quite some people here don’t seem keen to share their molds or even the needed details for others to reproduce and get us actually going somewhere. That can have as said many reasons but at the end it’s quite sad ending for all of us.
however, i am more the guy who just does, ignoring and leaving all that copyright/patent crap aside and so I started a PP mold directory, stay tuned! I think I have something to share in the next 2 weeks (v-clip, piranha clip and some other things :-). I have to create first some more infrastructure: new forum, and some other goodies to make proper development in this mold/pp story because unfortunately the PP team is too slow to adapt to user needs here. lets see in Sept. for v4, i hope it’s addressing finally R&D
Yes we will share the drawings. Licensed under a CC BY-SA 4.0
These are the files we used. pick what you need.
thanks a million kunststoffschmiede for sharing and caring !
I’ve modeled the CAM operations so far and from what i see now :
– 25 Euro for 6600 Aluminium
– around 14 hours (+/-5h) machining time (because of the narrow slots with a 2 mm ball end-mill) = 140 Euro (incl. electricity, end-mills, labor)
– 20 Euro Shipping
not sure where to place channel for the plastic entry yet, nor i don’t know this can be done actually with Dave’s default injection/extrusion machine but i will try my best to get it working for both. I know there is a tool to simulate injection molding…. anyone has suggestions ?
ps: finally pp got it’s first nice open-source mold
Thanks for sharing the design! I’m going to make a mould based your cad files, if it turns out well I might even offer it in the Bazaar so people can make their own Piranhaclamps locally (makes more sense than shipping the actual clamps around the world). If I do, I will of course give you the proper attribution you deserve for coming up with this.
Ok, here’s my first go at making this mould. Made one small Ooops, set the machine origin in the wrong place on the first half! But not a disaster, was able to recover it. I moved the injection point to where I prefer it, added a gate, and threaded it M10. I haven’t used the toggle clamp system before, I’ll see how it works out. I made the whole mould a bit smaller to save material (kept the same dimensions of the Piranhaclamp obviously).
Now to test it!
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.